In my opinion, Shyamalan shoots himself in the foot with almost every movie by trying to blow your mind somehow. In The Village, I was really enjoying my second viewing up to the point where he tries to convince the audience that maybe the creatures really do exist after all. We are shown the truth before hand, and yet Shyamalan feels obligated to shoot Brody's death scene in a horror style with grating noises and spooky suspense. Showing us the blind woman's fear and doubt is great, but you don't have to try to fool the audience as well. At least, not in the one-scene cheap trick way it was done here.
Then there is the cheesy scene towards the end after the preserve patrolman has helped the woman back over the wall where the truck is just sits in the middle of the road with melancholy music playing. They might as well have put up a giant banner that said "Isn't this profound, guys?!" I feel like pulling that card required more development of the patrolman's character.
So that's my shallow criticism, even though I did enjoy the movie quite a bit. I would like to go back and watch other Shyamalan movies now. However, I am a little scared to watch Lady in the Water again, because I think I might be the only person I know who actually enjoyed it the first time. It's just ridiculous enough to be enjoyed scene for scene (minus the M. Night plays a brilliant writer who will change the face of humanity part).

And now I feel good for reviving this blog. (sarcasm)